My favorite was the first season, but I enjoyed all the seasons. I loved the use of found footage to tell the story and how that effects what information is revealed. I loved the monologues and how the narrators deliver them, and how each narrator is obviously unreliable in their own way. For the first season, I enjoyed the mystery and the narrator's increasing distress while trying to keep someone else calm, and her frustration despite how much she cares. The backstory is revealed in an interesting manner. In the second season, I enjoyed how the paintings were described. In the third and fourth, I enjoyed seeing a different perspective on the podcast's world. If I were to have one main listening complaint, it would be that the ad placement in the middle of the show is irritating, especially since there are already ads at the beginning and end.