Thomas Tuchel: Pep’s Disciple Who Will Have No Problem Making Tough Decisions

Thomas Tuchel: Pep’s Disciple Who Will Have No Problem Making Tough Decisions

Released Thursday, 17th October 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Thomas Tuchel: Pep’s Disciple Who Will Have No Problem Making Tough Decisions

Thomas Tuchel: Pep’s Disciple Who Will Have No Problem Making Tough Decisions

Thomas Tuchel: Pep’s Disciple Who Will Have No Problem Making Tough Decisions

Thomas Tuchel: Pep’s Disciple Who Will Have No Problem Making Tough Decisions

Thursday, 17th October 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:01

Introducing the new Versed Limitless

0:03

Pant Collection. Re-imagined to deliver

0:05

effortless style, mobility, and comfort,

0:07

the new Limitless Collection features

0:09

moisture wicking, four-way stretch fabric

0:11

that's wrinkle resistant, and doesn't

0:13

lose fit. Plus, the

0:15

updated design offers a functional and

0:18

classic look with unmatched versatility. The

0:21

new Versed Limitless Pant Collection. Pants

0:23

made for movement. Available only

0:25

at Dicks Sporting Goods. Shop

0:27

now at dicks.com/Limitless. This

0:32

episode is brought to you by Coke Zero Sugar.

0:34

Being a fan takes a lot. Whether

0:36

it's loving your team through the lows

0:38

and the highs, or stocking up for

0:40

tailgates and getting pumped up for the

0:42

big game. Maybe it's a celebration with

0:44

old friends. A new one's too. But

0:47

whatever it is, it's thirsty work.

0:49

So drink something worth celebrating. Coke

0:52

Zero Sugar. Incredible taste, zero sugar.

0:55

Best Coke ever. This

0:58

episode is brought to you by Indeed. We're

1:01

driven by the search for better. But when it

1:03

comes to hiring, the best way to search for

1:05

a candidate isn't to search at all. Don't

1:08

search, match with Indeed. Use

1:11

Indeed for scheduling, screening, and messaging

1:13

so you can connect with candidates

1:15

faster. Listeners of this

1:18

show will get a $75

1:20

sponsored job credit to get

1:22

your jobs more visibility at

1:24

indeed.com/MBO. Terms and conditions apply.

1:36

Hello and welcome to the Restis Football

1:38

with just me, Gary Lineker, at the

1:41

moment. But I am joined for a

1:43

special edition, given the news that we

1:45

now have a new England coach in

1:47

Thomas Tuchl. A German coach, of course.

1:49

So I thought it might be quite

1:51

fitting. To speak to someone that knows

1:53

all about German football, knows all about

1:56

Thomas Tuchl. He's been a top journalist.

1:58

I've known him for a long time.

2:00

I'm working together for

2:02

BT. A warm welcome

2:04

to Raphael Hernigstein. Hernigstein.

2:07

I've not tried. I tried my best.

2:09

Thank you, Gary. I think it's the

2:11

only app that you start to speak

2:13

German properly now under these circumstances. Yes.

2:15

Das ist gut. My first question about

2:18

our new manager. How do we say

2:20

Thomas Tuchel? Is it Thomas Tuchel or

2:22

Thomas Tuchel? What is it? We need

2:24

to get that right, don't we, for

2:26

a start? Thomas Tuchel.

2:28

The Scousers will find it easier to

2:31

pronounce. I

2:33

think they will. Did it take you by

2:35

surprise? Yes and no. I mean, that's most

2:37

of the time the answer in these things.

2:40

But as soon as it became clear that

2:42

the FA were determined to get a big

2:44

name in rather than somebody had to be

2:46

English, then he was clearly the best candidate.

2:48

Pep was not available. Clop was not available.

2:50

Where else can you go? Thomas Tuchel was

2:53

a logical candidate. And he was really angling

2:55

for a job in England. He wanted to

2:57

be back in England. He loved it at

2:59

Chelsea. He kept on talking even at Bayern

3:01

Munich when he was boss there, how much

3:03

he loves working with English players, how the

3:06

dressing room mentality is good in brackets,

3:08

is not as good in Germany, brackets

3:11

closed. And I think he was so

3:13

willing to listen when they came knocking

3:16

that from that perspective, it did not

3:18

surprise me at all. And here we'll look at that

3:21

squad of multi-talented players, won't you, and

3:23

think, I've got half a chance

3:25

to win something, do something really special here. Yeah,

3:27

100%. It's not just that.

3:29

I mean, the squad is wonderful, especially in

3:31

the final third of the pitch. So much

3:33

talent. But also, unlike at Bayern,

3:35

unlike at PSG, unlike at Chelsea, unlike at

3:38

Dortmund, where he had always issues at some

3:40

stage with the people above him, there is

3:42

no one above him that's going to say

3:44

to him, we're going to buy this player,

3:46

we're going to buy that player, we want

3:48

you to play this guy, or

3:50

that guy's out of contract, we want you to put him

3:52

on the bench. Or you know what, what

3:54

do you think about buying this guy? None

3:56

of these things that have rubbed them the

3:58

wrong way, that bothered him in his

4:01

recent jobs apply. I

4:03

think that is the beauty of it. You

4:05

have the full control. You don't like a

4:08

particular player. He's not under contract. You just

4:10

stop calling him up. If somebody upstairs doesn't

4:12

like it, they're not going to say anything.

4:14

It's all down to you. So I think

4:16

he will absolutely relish that

4:18

power that comes with being the one person

4:21

and the only person that matters when it

4:23

comes to the squad. Did he generally wrestle

4:25

with those kind of problems, did he, at

4:27

his previous clubs? I mean, we know it

4:29

kind of fell out at Chelsea at the

4:32

end, obviously at Bayern Munich as well. PSG

4:35

always brings its problems because he's quite

4:37

volatile, isn't he? He is outspoken. He

4:39

can be quite stubborn. He can be

4:41

a little bit too honest for his

4:43

own good at times. All these things

4:46

came to the fore when there are

4:48

differences in opinion on certain players. To

4:50

just take Bayern as the most recent

4:52

example, he was very vocal about wanting

4:54

a holding midfield aboard for him. When

4:57

Bayern didn't do that, for whatever reason,

4:59

he was left with the players he

5:01

had to begin with. But having

5:03

spent two, three weeks, sometimes months talking

5:06

about all the things they can't do

5:08

and explaining why he needed somebody else.

5:11

So as you can imagine, once you've done

5:13

that, the trust, the relationship isn't quite the

5:15

same with these players. And to a similar

5:18

extent with the people above, when there are

5:20

differences in opinion, Tuchel has been very vocal,

5:22

didn't hold back at times. And that certainly

5:24

was a big problem with Dortmund. PSG fell

5:27

out with the sporting director Leonardo, who admittedly

5:29

tried to interfere on the training ground, which

5:31

I don't think would have gone down well

5:34

with any coach really. And Chelsea, it worked

5:36

really well under the old ownership and then

5:38

the new ownership, which I think have their

5:40

own issues, were

5:43

far too over-Baring, I think, for

5:45

his taste. And that thing did

5:47

not last. So international football might

5:49

suit him. Let's go back

5:51

to the start. What was his career in

5:53

terms of being a football? He didn't play

5:55

that often. He's not got too many games

5:57

under his belt. Why was that? Like many-

6:00

of those coaches who come out of nowhere

6:02

because he had to finish his career really

6:04

early, got a serious knee injury, playing

6:07

for Ulm under Ralf Rangnick, had to

6:09

start coaching or wanted to become a

6:11

coach early on in his 20s and

6:13

was given a bit of a break.

6:15

He initially did some scouting, I think,

6:17

and while studying for a degree and

6:19

working in a bar in

6:21

a pretty hipster place in Stuttgart with a

6:24

hipster haircut while he still had a

6:26

bit more hair, he

6:28

started coaching. Then quickly

6:30

rose through the youth ranks and

6:32

then had an opportunity when Mainz

6:34

fired their manager very early on

6:36

into the season. The manager had

6:38

succeeded Klopp, incidentally, was suddenly

6:41

promoted from the under 23s because he'd

6:43

won the championship with them, and then

6:45

became a really transformative manager at Mainz,

6:47

then Dortmund, and the rest. Alex Blauw

6:49

He's kind of a very similar path

6:51

in some ways to Klopp.

6:53

Paul Jay Yeah, I mean Klopp was

6:55

a legit second division player. He played

6:57

hundreds of games, so he had a

6:59

proper career. Alex Blauw Yeah, I'm talking

7:01

about in terms of the coaching path.

7:03

Yeah. Paul Jay Yeah, 100%. You went

7:05

from Mainz to Dortmund, but then from

7:07

Dortmund not to Liverpool, but to Wembley

7:09

via Paris and Munich. Alex

7:12

Blauw I remember talking to you about him

7:14

when he was getting the Chelsea job. You

7:16

said, I can't remember the percentages, but something

7:18

like 60 or 70% genius

7:20

and 30% lunatic,

7:22

mad, whatever word, like volatile, whatever word you

7:24

want to use. Does that still apply? Paul

7:27

Jay That was a quote. I'm not sure

7:29

percentages are quite right, but that was a

7:31

quote from his biography.

7:33

They had talked to somebody who

7:35

said, those two things are kind

7:37

of always present, and

7:39

sometimes the percentages switch one

7:42

way or the other. That was the quote.

7:44

And I think there's

7:47

some truth in it because he can

7:49

be, when he doesn't like a particular

7:51

player, he can be very brutal, very

7:53

harsh. Players getting banished from the team

7:56

hotel on the day of

7:58

a cup final, if they're not in the school.

8:00

and things like that where you think, okay, this

8:02

is a bit extreme. There's some really funny

8:05

old videos where he talks to

8:07

a player at Mainz and tells him in

8:09

front of the whole team, what

8:12

is this football you're playing? This is not our football.

8:14

I don't know what you have a million ideas, but

8:16

none of them are relevant to our football and

8:19

really gives him a massive dressing gown. And

8:22

so he has that edge

8:24

to him. Can be a little bit

8:26

cold-hearted, I think, that's fair to say.

8:28

Yeah, the genius side of it though,

8:30

is that presumably the coaching and his

8:34

vision and imagination for football?

8:36

I think so. I think

8:38

he understands and sees football

8:40

not far removed from

8:42

the level that Pep Guardiola is at, where

8:44

he looks at a game and sees the

8:46

patterns and sees the things that most of

8:49

us, certainly I, miss first time around. Maybe

8:51

I have to watch this game three or

8:53

four times and then I see it. These

8:55

guys see it instantly. They have discussions about

8:57

esoteric subjects that no one can

8:59

follow. They had this famous meeting of Mainz

9:02

in Munich in the

9:05

bar when Pep was coaching at Bayern and

9:07

he very graciously worked on Tucho because he

9:09

was impressed with his coaching. They talked about

9:11

football for hours and hours using

9:14

peppermills and glasses to do the

9:16

formations on the pitch. Somebody

9:19

told me that in the beginning, a lot of people

9:21

tried to listen in. And then

9:23

as they realized that they couldn't understand

9:25

what they're talking about, more and more

9:27

people just gave up. And in the

9:29

end, there was just one or two

9:32

left. So he definitely has, I think,

9:34

a feel and understanding of the game

9:37

that is up there with the elite coaches.

9:39

What's interesting with him is that in the

9:41

beginning, he used to be very much a

9:44

Pep Guardiola disciple. He

9:47

loved Guardiola. He wanted to be like Guardiola.

9:49

The football is very free flowing. And what

9:51

happened was as he moved to PSG, realizing

9:53

that there is no way that I'm going

9:56

to get Messi and Neymar to

9:58

press or to play any sort of patterns

10:00

that I want, I'll just have to kind

10:02

of relax and let them do their thing.

10:04

He became more and more pragmatic and adjusted

10:07

more and more to the situation. At Chelsea,

10:09

you remember you played with a back three

10:11

and it was quite a pragmatic, sometimes very

10:13

defensive, reactive setup. At Bayern,

10:15

he couldn't play that way in terms

10:17

of formation, but often the football was

10:20

also a little bit reactive. He wanted

10:22

his team to sit and

10:24

absorb the pressure and then have more

10:26

space to attack and play a little

10:28

bit on the break. And it didn't

10:30

really go down so well with the

10:32

fans, with the players, and with some

10:34

people on the board. So

10:36

I'm really excited and interested to see what

10:39

kind of total blueprint will emerge, because I

10:41

think his instinct is still to be an

10:44

attacking manager, but he's often found himself being

10:46

more problematic when he feels that

10:48

this team or these players

10:50

can't quite play that way. He will

10:52

actually play something completely different

10:55

with them. It will be interesting to

10:57

see because obviously the criticisms of the

10:59

previous coach, even though obviously he did

11:01

very well in terms of two finals,

11:04

a semifinal and a quarterfinal in four

11:06

major tournaments, which are record better than

11:08

anyone else previously. But the downside for

11:10

most people, most critics, was that he

11:13

was a very, very cautious and more

11:15

than pragmatic coach. So

11:17

do you think Tuchl will

11:19

look at that and think, look

11:22

probably what he's got available to him

11:24

in terms of the plethora of attacking

11:26

footballers and adapt to that and play

11:28

a more imaginative attacking game? I

11:31

mean, this is the interesting question. I don't

11:33

know. He could well

11:35

feel that, you know, this imbalance that England

11:37

have, they're so top heavy with all the

11:40

talent being on one side of the pitch,

11:42

that the solution is not to have them

11:45

all play, but actually to have few of

11:47

them play and make some

11:49

tough decisions and leave some of those performers

11:51

out, but have more stability and play a

11:53

more balanced game or pragmatic game.

11:55

Or he might feel the opposite. He might

11:57

say, we can only play this particular way. with

12:00

his team. But the interesting thing at Bayern

12:02

was that he felt because he

12:04

doesn't have a holding midfielder, you can't

12:06

play this expensive passing game because every

12:08

counter attack they kill you. Now we

12:10

see Bayern without him with basically the

12:12

identical team playing this Guardiola

12:14

type football under company and

12:17

people saying we can't quite understand what Tucho was

12:19

on about. In the end it became a self-fulfilling

12:21

prophecy because as you know sometimes when coaches don't

12:23

get their way the board will say well thank

12:25

god we didn't let him buy all these players

12:28

because we got rid of him and now we

12:30

would have stuck with the players. But he can

12:32

say well I never got my players, I never

12:34

had a real chance of playing the

12:36

football I wanted to. Which goes back to the

12:38

earlier point, he's not going to have a problem.

12:40

He can pick and choose and do whatever he

12:43

wants with perhaps the exception of I think Harry

12:45

Kane and maybe Saka who can't

12:47

leave out. He's going to be his own man

12:49

and he's going to decide and I can tell

12:51

you one thing he's not going to be interested

12:53

in whether people say it's not entertaining enough or

12:55

it's too negative. If he feels this

12:58

is the best way to win games he's

13:00

just going to play like that. Okay let's

13:02

take a little breather and when we come

13:04

back I want to talk about a few

13:06

more things about Thomas Trujal but mainly about

13:08

what they think about it in Germany. We'll

13:10

be back in a minute. This.

13:14

Episode has brought to you by state for

13:16

he might say all kinds of stuff of

13:18

things go wrong but these are the words

13:20

you really need to remember. Like a Good

13:22

Neighbor State Farm is there. They've got options

13:25

to fit your unique insurance league. It's meaning

13:27

you can talk to your age to choose

13:29

the coverage unique, have coverage options to protect

13:31

the things you value most. file a claim

13:34

right on the state or mobile app and

13:36

even reach a real person when you need

13:38

to talk to someone like a Good Neighbor

13:40

State Farm. Is there? This episode

13:42

is brought to you by Indeed. We're

13:45

driven by the search for better but when

13:47

it comes to hiring the best way to

13:49

search for a candidate isn't to search at

13:51

all. Don't search match

13:53

with Indeed. Use Indeed

13:55

for scheduling, screening and messaging so

13:58

you can connect with candidates. faster.

14:01

Listeners of this show will

14:03

get a $75-sponsored job credit

14:05

to get your jobs more

14:07

visibility at nd.com/MBO. Terms

14:09

and conditions apply. It

14:12

feels like you can get your credit scores anywhere these

14:14

days. Random websites, card statements,

14:16

budgeting apps, heck, even your dog might bark

14:18

out a few numbers. It's

14:21

true, credit karma isn't the only place you can

14:23

find them. But we actually do

14:25

more with your scores to help you find your next

14:27

financial opportunity. Make a more rewarding credit

14:29

card, a game plan that helps you pay down

14:31

debt faster, or a personal loan to help you

14:34

save more on interest payments each month. Cha-ching! The

14:36

possibilities are kinda endless. Download

14:39

Intuit Credit Karma today to get started. Welcome

14:45

back to the Restage Football with

14:48

me, Garren Ilica and Raphael Hönigstein.

14:50

Raphael, in Germany, what are they

14:52

saying? German coach

14:54

managing England, what are they saying? I'd

14:56

be fascinated to know. Well, so far,

14:58

I haven't really seen any big think

15:01

pieces or big opinions. I think it's

15:03

just very matter of fact, hooray, there's

15:05

another German manager in a top position

15:07

that reflects well on German football, reflects

15:09

well on German coaching. It's

15:11

England and Wembley, four places, which is

15:13

really seen as something quite sacred

15:15

and something, you know, hallowed turf

15:17

and so on. And I think people

15:19

by and large are just sort of proud that

15:21

there is a German at the helm of this storied

15:24

football nation. I think that is the

15:26

groundswell of opinion. When it goes towards

15:29

tournaments and maybe, you know, God forbid

15:31

we play each other in the

15:34

knockouts and it goes to penalties, I don't know

15:36

what's going to happen. The final, it's written in

15:38

the stars. It's going to be written in the

15:40

stars. England, Germany, final, penalty shootout. For the time.

15:43

And at the end, the German always wins. Not

15:46

the Germans. One German or more Germans will

15:48

win. I don't know

15:50

if maybe opinion will change. My best

15:52

hunch is that it won't because for

15:54

two reasons. One, as I said, I

15:57

think people think it's cool as a

15:59

German manager coaching in. is a cool

16:01

thing. And second, there is no real

16:03

dislike towards England as a football nation.

16:05

If anything, it's a sort of mild,

16:07

positive attitude. We look

16:09

up to England, we like English football. We

16:12

sometimes make fun of them when

16:14

they don't win, which happens not

16:17

so frequently anymore. Unfortunately, they win

16:19

too much for my taste. But

16:21

you know what it's like. There's a bento,

16:24

but it's much more good-natured,

16:26

I would say, from our perspective

16:29

than this more sort of

16:31

real animosity that we, for example, have

16:34

with the Italians and the Dutch. England

16:36

is a much milder rivalry. And

16:39

of course, it's also easier to

16:41

have good relations with a nation

16:43

that doesn't win anything. So that's

16:46

helped in the last 60 or so

16:48

years. Well, let's

16:50

hope a German can change that.

16:52

I think looking at Thomas, I

16:54

talked about it on our podcast,

16:57

we did an emergency podcast that went

16:59

out earlier. On that, we talked about

17:01

an FA Cup tie at

17:04

Barnsley, where Chelsea were playing. And it was

17:06

during COVID, so there's no crowd. So you

17:08

could hear everything, which is really unusual. You

17:11

could hear everything that was coming from the

17:13

bench. Wow, boy, oh boy, he's got a

17:15

bit of a temper to him. And he

17:18

was very encouraging at times, but also

17:20

very, very demanding of his players as

17:22

well, which will be interesting to see

17:24

how that pans out. And obviously, it's

17:26

slightly different to club football, because you

17:28

can probably rotate a little bit more

17:30

in club football and bring players different

17:32

ones in. But when you've got this

17:34

much talent, it will have that problem

17:36

that any coach, which is not a

17:38

bad problem, really, is to try and

17:40

keep happy, incredibly talented players

17:42

that are not in the starting 11.

17:45

Yeah, 100%. And that is my one

17:47

concern, if that is indeed the

17:49

right word for this role, because he is

17:52

not the most empathetic

17:54

of managers. He's not really somebody

17:56

who creates a huge emotional bond

17:58

between him and the players, between

18:00

the players and each other. It's

18:02

not his way of doing things.

18:04

He's very technical. Lots of

18:06

players don't want it any other way. They don't

18:08

want the hugs. They don't want all this other

18:10

stuff. They're just happy that somebody can help them

18:12

to play better on the pitch. But when it

18:14

comes to fostering this kind of relationship that you

18:16

perhaps need, if you're all together for four or

18:18

five weeks in the same spot,

18:20

unlike with club football, where you'll go home

18:23

after a few hours, this is something I

18:25

think you'll need to adapt to and perhaps

18:27

add another string to his ball. Because you're

18:30

right to point at his body language

18:33

at Bayern, even in a full stadium. You could

18:35

so often see him shaking his

18:37

head or demonstrating with his coach,

18:39

saying, you know, what are these guys doing?

18:42

Afterwards, he would come out and say

18:44

in the press, we had a really

18:47

good plan, but the players did something

18:49

completely different today. And that's

18:51

why things didn't work out. So if

18:53

he doesn't, I think, find common ground

18:55

also on an emotional level with England

18:58

players, I think it's going to be

19:00

more difficult to create the kind of

19:02

positive environment that Garrosavge so clearly managed

19:05

to implement. And I think that is one

19:08

of the main reasons that England have had this consistency.

19:10

They might not have had the

19:12

tactical acumen and competence that Tucho

19:14

will bring, but under the base

19:16

of it was a lot more

19:18

about the culture, the emotions. And

19:21

I'm not sure he's going to be able to

19:23

replicate that. He's a very different animal to Garrosavge.

19:26

That was his great strength, wasn't it? So they've

19:28

kind of gone from it's a drastic

19:30

change in styles in many

19:33

ways, certainly of personalities in the two coaches.

19:35

100%. And I think

19:37

that maybe the FA or the people

19:39

in charge underestimate just how different Tucho

19:42

is in the dressing room compared with

19:44

the charming erudite and sometimes

19:46

really funny Tucho that we see in

19:48

press conferences, because he doesn't quite manage

19:51

that way. And I hope it doesn't

19:53

come as a bit of a shock.

19:55

I mean, he loved English players and

19:58

wanted to get more English his

20:00

experience, they don't need

20:02

all this bodily

20:04

cuddling and this blanket around

20:07

them and ego massage, which

20:09

might be true, but I think it's still

20:11

different when you go to England because their

20:13

people go, not because they're under contract and

20:15

they're professional, because they feel something for the

20:17

shirt and they want to do something for

20:19

England. And I think that is maybe something

20:21

he hasn't yet

20:25

fully contemplated or

20:27

at least seen in action. And

20:30

I'm not sure the FA quite understand

20:32

just how different his personality can be

20:34

as opposed to the public persona. I

20:36

interviewed him, he's very charming. He

20:39

can be very charming in that sense, but once he gets

20:42

in that dressing room, he turns into a slightly

20:44

different animal. It's a bit like you, Gary. Absolutely,

20:49

a little dark side there somewhere. Why is

20:52

it that Germany are producing currently

20:54

so many top coaches? There's a few reasons for

20:56

this. First of all, you can be an under

20:58

23 coach and then

21:00

you'll be given the chance to actually

21:02

coach a Bundesliga side. Without that chance,

21:04

Touche might still be somewhere in the

21:06

under 23s. So not

21:09

only do we produce coaches, but

21:11

we produce the environment, the ability

21:13

for coaches to progress and being

21:15

seen. And that I think is

21:17

totally key. You know,

21:19

club former player gets a job at Mainz,

21:22

Touche under 23 coach gets a

21:24

job at Mainz, Nagelsmann

21:26

under 23 coach at Hoffenheim

21:28

gets the seniors job at

21:30

Hoffenheim. Tedesco is another

21:32

one. We have, I think the openness

21:35

and people taking a chance on coaches like

21:37

that. Then of course they still have to

21:39

do well. They still have to show that

21:41

they know what they're doing. And I think

21:43

they know what they're doing because they are

21:46

just obsessed workers. These are people who, 24

21:48

hours a day, think

21:50

about football, work on training

21:53

practices, watch the games back

21:55

three or four times, try to come up

21:57

with new ideas, try to find an...

22:00

edge and they do so because again

22:02

in their clubs, they would

22:04

have come for a system where you cannot

22:06

simply buy three or four players to improve

22:08

the team. The improvement has to come more

22:10

often than not through the coaching. That

22:13

is your real edge. So it's

22:15

a different culture. And the

22:17

third reason is that I think they

22:19

have grown up in the model

22:22

where you have shared responsibilities,

22:24

they're coaches rather than managers.

22:27

They think about coaching and

22:30

when it comes to, let's say, a

22:32

big English club signing a manager and somebody

22:34

comes in and says, I don't want

22:36

to buy all the players. I

22:38

don't want to tell you who the best

22:41

under 16 manager is. I just want to

22:43

coach my first team. You do the rest.

22:45

That is hugely attractive for these owners. So

22:47

they also like this way

22:49

of doing things that a lot of

22:51

the German coaches have. Does it surprise

22:53

you that the lack of success that

22:55

English coaches have had? German coaches have

22:57

got way, way more trophies for English

23:00

clubs than English coaches. It matters. Why

23:02

doesn't England produce these kind of coaches?

23:04

I think it's because of the way

23:06

the Premier League works. I think the

23:08

Premier League is a league that attracts

23:10

the best players from all over the

23:12

world. And it's just easy

23:14

to say who has won the league in

23:16

Germany, who has won the league in Portugal,

23:18

rather than getting, as used to be the

23:21

case, somebody from Scotland or

23:23

somebody who's just done really well

23:25

in the championship. It just doesn't

23:27

have that natural progression for English

23:29

coaches. When was the

23:31

last time that you heard about an

23:33

under 23 or a youth coach being

23:35

promoted to a senior job in English

23:37

football anywhere? Talking about club football. So

23:39

it just doesn't happen. So these coaches,

23:42

they don't really have

23:44

the ability to learn on the job.

23:46

It's very, very difficult if you have

23:48

a lot of supply, but no real

23:51

demand, no real possibility to

23:53

grow as a coach, to keep progressing

23:55

in an orderly fashion is hard. You're

23:58

looking at three or four coaches. who perhaps

24:00

were only in contention for the job, Potter

24:02

and Eddie Howe, and I'm already struggling to

24:05

name you a third one. It's because we

24:07

haven't seen too many English managers in the

24:09

Premier League to begin with. So the

24:12

pond is very shallow. Tournament football

24:14

is different by its nature than

24:16

Premier League, Bundesliga, Ligue, La

24:18

Liga, any of them. It's very different,

24:21

isn't it? That environment, that month together

24:23

for a major tournament. How do you

24:25

think he'll cope with that difference? Well,

24:28

England have to qualify first, of course, but let's

24:30

assume that they do. I'm

24:32

getting ahead of myself. My apologies. That's

24:34

part of our problem. Yeah. Book the

24:37

tickets now. No,

24:39

I'm sure they will qualify. And it's a great

24:42

question because it's going to be completely new for

24:44

him. Covid, I think, had an

24:46

element of that because at least

24:48

as a coaching team, they were stuck in a hotel

24:51

together for weeks and months and

24:53

kind of enjoyed it. I

24:55

know he enjoyed it very much, working like

24:58

that without any distractions. But of

25:00

course, the same wasn't true of the players. And

25:02

I think he will have to either through

25:04

the coaching staff who does some of that

25:06

role for him quite well or

25:09

through himself develop more of an

25:11

emotional approach and

25:13

become a bit more approachable, a bit more

25:15

personable when it comes to talking to his

25:17

players, because these things, I think, do matter

25:19

when you spend so much time together and

25:22

you feel that the coach is very aloof

25:24

and very standoffish. It certainly I

25:26

think was a problem with Fabio Capello. Credits

25:28

were never in doubt as far as his

25:30

ability is concerned, but it didn't really seem

25:32

to have any kind of connection with his

25:34

players. I suppose that it will help the

25:37

fact that he's had experience of English footballs,

25:39

no doubt about that. Last question, have we

25:41

made a good appointment? I think so. Thomas

25:43

Tuchel, if I go back to

25:45

what I said earlier, if you are determined to

25:47

get a proven winner, you don't care what passport

25:49

he has, perhaps secretly you actually like that he's

25:51

not English. I don't know what

25:53

they were thinking, but it seems to

25:55

me that way there aren't that many

25:57

coaches of his caliber available. I'm sure

25:59

they looked at Guardiola. had no chance.

26:01

They looked at Klopp, had no chance.

26:04

I think once you are on that

26:06

shelf, on that bracket, looking at this

26:08

kind of calibre, you go to Tomastocho

26:10

quite naturally. But I think that change

26:12

from the England Klopp culture

26:14

that Geras Elfgaard has been able

26:16

to instill to a more, let's

26:18

say, technocratic approach or technical approach

26:21

might not be as smooth as

26:23

some people anticipate. Plus one more

26:25

thing, this is going to be

26:27

a very specialised sort of pressure

26:29

because usually you come in and

26:32

your job is to win and if

26:34

you win enough games, that's good enough. I

26:36

think with Tuchel, my sense is that anything

26:38

but making it to the final and winning

26:40

the workup is going to be seen as

26:43

failure after the run that Geras Elfgaard has

26:45

had. And I think that makes it very

26:47

difficult for any coach. If the difference between

26:49

success and failure is winning effectively the workup

26:51

or at least making it to the final,

26:53

then that doesn't leave you a lot of

26:55

room for errors. So

26:57

it's going to be pretty hard, I

26:59

think, despite England's wonderful talent. It's win

27:01

or bust. We'll see how it goes.

27:04

Rafa, thank you so much. Thank you,

27:06

Sean. See you again. Goodbye, everyone. I'm

27:14

Marina Hyde. And I'm Richard Osman.

27:16

And together we host The Rest

27:18

is Entertainment. It's your weekly fix

27:20

of entertainment news, reviews, splash of

27:23

showbiz gossip. And on our Q&A

27:25

we pull back the curtain on

27:27

entertainment and we tell you how

27:29

it all works. We have just

27:31

launched our Members Club. If you

27:33

want ad-free listening bonus episodes and

27:35

early access to live tickets, head

27:37

to therestisentertainment.com. That's therestisentertainment.com.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features